Difference between revisions of "Variant Rules"
m (→Haggling) |
|||
Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
==Haggling== | ==Haggling== | ||
− | ''The Legend of Zelda'' infrequently has the protagonist change the prices a shopkeeper initially offers, and ''Dungeons & Dragons'' doesn't include any guidance to haggle in their core rules. This is for good reason. At the table, haggling can feel like a lot of time and effort focused on something trivial—barely changing the price of an item—which only affects one player at the table anyway. To have any real consequence, | + | ''The Legend of Zelda'' infrequently has the protagonist change the prices a shopkeeper initially offers, and ''Dungeons & Dragons'' doesn't include any guidance to haggle in their core rules. This is for good reason. At the table, haggling can feel like a lot of time and effort focused on something trivial—barely changing the price of an item—which only affects one player at the table anyway. To have any real consequence, haggling also requires robbing a player of agency—if they can turn down any offer they don't like, there's no reason not to ''always'' haggle for a better price—which isn't very satisfying to many ''D&D'' players.{{a}}Still, haggling can feel much more substantial if for example the entire party is pooling their resources together to buy one incredibly powerful magic item. Some players enjoy haggling regardless, so these steps offer a streamlined option that can be used without bogging down the game with economical jargon and trivial pursuits. Use this option sparingly. If a player asks to haggle over something petty or does so too often, feel free to have a shopkeeper decline. "Just buy somethin' will ya!"{{a}}These steps function the same whether the players are buying or selling. |
− | #'''''Offer.''''' The NPC offers a fair market price based on | + | #'''''Offer.''''' The NPC offers a fair market price based on [[equipment]], [[Magic_Item_Overview|magic items]], or whatever you think is a reasonable price. If you already expect the players will haggle, add a little bit to the price in the NPC's favor—maybe 10% or so. As usual, the price is halved if the players are selling instead of buying. |
#'''''Counteroffer.''''' The player(s) make their argument or counter offer. Make it clear to the players that: '''If you haggle, there is a chance your characters will ''swindled'' into accepting or making a payment you regret.''' | #'''''Counteroffer.''''' The player(s) make their argument or counter offer. Make it clear to the players that: '''If you haggle, there is a chance your characters will ''swindled'' into accepting or making a payment you regret.''' | ||
− | #'''''Arbitrate.''''' Depending on the strength of the players' approach, you decide whether to give them [[advantage]] or [[disadvantage]] on their check. If it's particularly impactful, you could also decide to give the | + | #'''''Arbitrate.''''' Depending on the strength of the players' approach, you decide whether to give them [[advantage]] or [[disadvantage]] on their check. If it's particularly impactful, you could also decide to give the NPC a disadvantage or advantage too. The NPC may also be affected by spells or other game effects which affect its ability check. |
− | #'''''Ability Check.''''' The players make an ability check as appropriate, usually [[Charisma]] ([[Persuasion]]), and the | + | #'''''Ability Check.''''' The players make an ability check as appropriate, usually [[Charisma]] ([[Persuasion]]), and the NPC makes their opposed ability check. If you don't have ability scores in mind for the NPC, consider giving them at least a +2 on their check, since they are probably skilled at their profession if they're confident enough to haggle. Particularly prestigious merchants of magic items and estates might have a +5 or higher. Use the normal rule for [[Using_Ability_Scores#Working_Together|group ability check]]s if multiple player-characters haggle together. Something like the [[Help]] action shouldn't afford an advantage. |
− | #'''''Result.''''' If the players win, the price is | + | #'''''Result.''''' If the players win, the price is adjusted by ''about'' a quarter (25%) in their favor, though feel free to go for about a third (33.3%) or a fifth (20%) instead.{{a}}{{tab}}If the players win by 5 or more, the price instead adjusts in their favor by 50% (2d4 × 10%).{{a}}{{tab}}If the NPC wins, the price adjusts in their favor by 50% (2d4 × 10%){{a}}{{tab}}If the NPC wins by 5 or more, the player-characters are swindled into paying the adjusted regardless of whether or not the players still want to pay. |
− | #'''''Pay Up.''''' At this point the players can either take the price | + | #'''''Pay Up.''''' At this point the players can either take the price if not already forced to do so, or give up on the transaction. The NPC will never change their price. |
When using this rule, it is best to use the default value for buying and selling magic items. Rolling to haggle ''and'' rolling for random magic item prices can result in overly extreme disparities in price.{{a}}There's no need to stick to {{cha}} ([[Persuasion]]) as the ability check. Maybe the players will use [[Intimidation]]. Arguably a {{wis}} ([[Insight]]) check could work, too. An {{int}} could certainly fit, drawing on knowledge of market values and an astute appraisal of the item. For certain personalities, the players might even be able to wager the outcome of something like a sumo wrestling match—thus making it a {{str}} ([[Athletics]]) check in this case. | When using this rule, it is best to use the default value for buying and selling magic items. Rolling to haggle ''and'' rolling for random magic item prices can result in overly extreme disparities in price.{{a}}There's no need to stick to {{cha}} ([[Persuasion]]) as the ability check. Maybe the players will use [[Intimidation]]. Arguably a {{wis}} ([[Insight]]) check could work, too. An {{int}} could certainly fit, drawing on knowledge of market values and an astute appraisal of the item. For certain personalities, the players might even be able to wager the outcome of something like a sumo wrestling match—thus making it a {{str}} ([[Athletics]]) check in this case. | ||
Revision as of 05:12, 23 October 2020
Please download an offline copy of any page you may need. "Alt+Shift+P" can be used to make a printable PDF of any page. See also archives. | ||
Player's Guide |
System Reference |
Compendium |
Contents
Advanced Character Creation
This page or section is incomplete, and will eventually be expanded with more information. |
This option offers guidance for creating a player character at a level higher than 1st.
Craft During Rest
This page or section is incomplete, and will eventually be expanded with more information. |
This option grants more opportunity for artisans to craft, and is best suited for campaigns which lack much downtime for this activity.
You must be proficient with an artisan's tool to craft during rest.
Group Initiative
This page or section is incomplete, and will eventually be expanded with more information. |
Haggling
The Legend of Zelda infrequently has the protagonist change the prices a shopkeeper initially offers, and Dungeons & Dragons doesn't include any guidance to haggle in their core rules. This is for good reason. At the table, haggling can feel like a lot of time and effort focused on something trivial—barely changing the price of an item—which only affects one player at the table anyway. To have any real consequence, haggling also requires robbing a player of agency—if they can turn down any offer they don't like, there's no reason not to always haggle for a better price—which isn't very satisfying to many D&D players.
Still, haggling can feel much more substantial if for example the entire party is pooling their resources together to buy one incredibly powerful magic item. Some players enjoy haggling regardless, so these steps offer a streamlined option that can be used without bogging down the game with economical jargon and trivial pursuits. Use this option sparingly. If a player asks to haggle over something petty or does so too often, feel free to have a shopkeeper decline. "Just buy somethin' will ya!"
These steps function the same whether the players are buying or selling.
- Offer. The NPC offers a fair market price based on equipment, magic items, or whatever you think is a reasonable price. If you already expect the players will haggle, add a little bit to the price in the NPC's favor—maybe 10% or so. As usual, the price is halved if the players are selling instead of buying.
- Counteroffer. The player(s) make their argument or counter offer. Make it clear to the players that: If you haggle, there is a chance your characters will swindled into accepting or making a payment you regret.
- Arbitrate. Depending on the strength of the players' approach, you decide whether to give them advantage or disadvantage on their check. If it's particularly impactful, you could also decide to give the NPC a disadvantage or advantage too. The NPC may also be affected by spells or other game effects which affect its ability check.
- Ability Check. The players make an ability check as appropriate, usually Charisma (Persuasion), and the NPC makes their opposed ability check. If you don't have ability scores in mind for the NPC, consider giving them at least a +2 on their check, since they are probably skilled at their profession if they're confident enough to haggle. Particularly prestigious merchants of magic items and estates might have a +5 or higher. Use the normal rule for group ability checks if multiple player-characters haggle together. Something like the Help action shouldn't afford an advantage.
- Result. If the players win, the price is adjusted by about a quarter (25%) in their favor, though feel free to go for about a third (33.3%) or a fifth (20%) instead.
If the players win by 5 or more, the price instead adjusts in their favor by 50% (2d4 × 10%).
If the NPC wins, the price adjusts in their favor by 50% (2d4 × 10%)
If the NPC wins by 5 or more, the player-characters are swindled into paying the adjusted regardless of whether or not the players still want to pay. - Pay Up. At this point the players can either take the price if not already forced to do so, or give up on the transaction. The NPC will never change their price.
When using this rule, it is best to use the default value for buying and selling magic items. Rolling to haggle and rolling for random magic item prices can result in overly extreme disparities in price.
There's no need to stick to Charisma (Persuasion) as the ability check. Maybe the players will use Intimidation. Arguably a Wisdom (Insight) check could work, too. An Intelligence could certainly fit, drawing on knowledge of market values and an astute appraisal of the item. For certain personalities, the players might even be able to wager the outcome of something like a sumo wrestling match—thus making it a Strength (Athletics) check in this case.
Poisons & Diseases
Although The Legend of Zelda features some effects which can arguably cause poison damage or even the poisoned condition, there is practically no canonical precedent for poison that can be administered as an agent—whether it would applied to a weapon or ingested. As such no such poisons are included in this compendium by default, not even "common poison." Similarly, there are very few instances of illness or disease with quantifiable symptoms. There is however no reason a DM could not include diseases, poisons, or both—whether from the Dungeon Master's Guide (page 256) or elsewhere.
Random Character Creation
This page or section is incomplete, and will eventually be expanded with more information. |
This option provides the means to decide every statistic of a player character by rolling dice, replacing the normal process character creation. All options herein are possible with normal character creation.
Tool Expertise
This page or section is incomplete, and will eventually be expanded with more information. |